
I recently recalled my painful experience of watching Hotel Rwanda. Nominated for three Academy Awards® and two Golden Globes®, Hotel Rwanda tells the true story of Paul Rusesabagina, a Hutu hotel manager who helped to save the life of over 1,200 Tutsi fugitives during the 1994 Rwandan conflict. As the nations of the world turned their heads, the Hutu military–assisted by gangs of radical extremists and the French army–conducted the most atrocious act of genocide in recent history as they slaughtered almost one million Tutsis and moderate Hutus.
The rivalry between Tutsi and Hutu had been going on for centuries. Originally inhabited by the pigmy Twa, Rwanda became home to a majority Hutu population about 1000 years ago. By the fifteenth century, the Tutsis had merged into the region and–although a minority–quickly gained political dominance. Tutsi mwamis (kings) ruled the region until the early twentieth century when power was ceded to Germany and eventually Belgium. In true colonial fashion, the Belgians encouraged minority Tutsi dominance until the late 1950s when Hutus successfully lobbied for a political voice.
As the Hutus grew politically stronger in the following decades, civil discord erupted and many Tutsis sought refuge in neighboring countries in an attempt to escape the growing numbers of vengeful Hutu leaders who called for the extermination of the Tutsi minority. The centuries old tribal rivalry culminated in the 1994 genocide when ethnic pride transformed tolerant neighbors into blood thirsty killers.
Failure of Christianity
When reflecting on the world’s complacency in the face of such a devastating tragedy, many view the genocide as a failure of humanity. Recently, former President Bill Clinton voiced his regret for not intervening in the massacre. Politically scarred by the loss of US marines in the Somalian conflict, he did not want to place more American troops in harms way. America was not alone in its feigned neutrality, none of the world’s “superpowers” attempted to stop the killing.
While the event does expose the dilapidated nature of humanity, I see it more as a failure of Christianity. As a result of missionary efforts, about 90% of the Rwandan population professed to be Christian (a Catholic majority with a strong Protestant minority). Every weekend teems of people crowded the narrow streets going to their places of worship on Saturdays and Sundays. In the weekdays, students attended church run schools and universities. However, when the command to slaughter was issued, it did not take long for dutiful churchgoers to transform their “plowshares into spears and their pruning hooks into swords” (cf. Joel 3:10).
They had been taught to be loyal to their denominations but had never been introduced to Christ. They had been catechized into creedal Christianity but had never been shown the Savior. They had been schooled in the memorization of scripture but had never witnessed what it means for God’s words to be hidden in the heart. They had been instructed to hate their culture but had never been encouraged to love their brother.
Triumph of Christ
Although many of the colonial missionary-masters presented a distorted version of Christianity, some Rwandans opened their heart to the Spirit’s voice and were ready to be witnesses in this “time of trouble.” In the midst of the maddening massacre, the Spirit of Messiah was mightily manifested in mysterious ways as some Hutus resisted the allure of the frenzied throng and provided refuge for the terrorized Tutsis. They realized that God has only one race–the human race–and we are all equal under heaven (Gal 3:28). While brother turned against brother, God’s remnant refused to succumb to ethnic pressure.
I believe that Paul Rusesbagina was one of God’s remnant. From the pharisaical standards of many professed Christians, the character portrayed in the movie would never have qualified for the kingdom. He had learned the ways of the world and did not think twice about doing favors for corrupt government officials or imbibing a shot of scotch on social occasions. He even uttered the odd curse word when he got upset. Many upstanding Christians would have viewed him as a heathen. However, when the time of testing came, this lapsed Seventh-day Adventist stood for godly principle and “did not love [his] life so much as to shrink from death” (Rev 12:11, TNIV).
He may not have exhibited adherence to archaic creeds crafted in ecclesiastical councils. He may not have had a perfect record of church attendance. He may not have conformed to a list of dietary restrictions or a puritan dress code. But when God called for a person to stand for him when it counted the most, Paul Rusesbagina said, “Here I am, send me!” Are you willing to be used by him? As you contemplate your response, always remember that “a tree is known by its fruit.”
Keith Augustus Burton teaches religion classes at Florida Hospital College of Health Sciences and Oakwood University. He is also the Executive Director of the non-profit organization, Life emPowerment, Inc., which encourages personal responsibility and community cooperation.
Mr. Rusesbagina Loved others supremely. And the world saw this & was struck by his devotion..Jesus Christ waits patiently for Christians to display His love.
Renee Hernandez
In Paul Rusesbagina I too see Jesus.
In a religious climate where the focus is on individual's perfection of behaviour in minutiae, while the bigger picture is often ignored, your insights, Keith, are valuable.
I see it not so much as a failure of Christianity as it is a testimony to the power of fear and the basic human instinct to survive. Rwanda is just one example of many we have witnessed where former friends and neighbors are forced apart by fear. If someone holds a gun to your head and says renounce (fill in ethnic group) or die, that is a tough decision. And once you fear X, and the X's fear you (Y), then the mutual fear builds its own momentum as the actions based on that fear lead to further fear, in a viscious cycle. Ethnic cleansing in any mixed ethnic region often seems to follow this pattern. Politicians can exploit it for their own purposes. So is this a failure of Christianity? To a degree, yes. But I think it is all too easy to sit in the USA and make this claim. It is a rare person who has the courage that Rusesbagina had.
BTW, why does your byline say you teach religion classes at FHC and OU when neither school's bulletin lists you as a professor or even adjunct instructor? Do you teach Sabbath School there or something?
I have taught at a university for more than 6 years and am not on any of their websites or bulletins. I am contracted often, sometimes whole semesters, sometimes for residential degree intensives, sometimes for lectures, but neither have nor seek permanent tenure because I have many other projects. Perhaps Keith is in a similar position. (Stop nitpicking - you are sounding like a literalist critical whiner)
"They had been taught to be loyal to their denominations but had never been introduced to Christ. They had been catechized into creedal Christianity but had never been shown the Savior. They had been schooled in the memorization of scripture but had never witnessed what it means for God’s words to be hidden in the heart. They had been instructed to hate their culture but had never been encouraged to love their brother."
I question the paragraph I quoted. It seems to put the blame on church leaders. When a religion is popular, in this case Christianity, it's easy to become a follower. But receiving God's word, His Son and His love in one's heart and dying to self is being born again. That's a personal decision, and those guided by God experience it; the others are stony ground, thorny ground and on the road hearers of God's word.
Jesus, like his Jewish countrymen, was far more concerned about the way people lived their lives than their metaphysical beliefs. Christians, on the contrary, focus their energy on mastering the arcana of orthodoxy. Christians all too often have used their energy to fight for what they see as their particular tribe's proprietary incantations instead of modeling their lives on Jesus, trying to make a difference in this world. The following example is all to typical:.
In mid 1840s Francis Parkman, a Boston Brahmin, set off from St. Louis on the wagon trail to Oregon. In Independence, Missouri they came upon a large group of "emigrants" who were preparing to head West. Then all of a sudden a rumor spread that 2500 Mormons from the town of St. Joseph were headed their way. "The women and children at Independence raised a great outcry, and, as I learned, they sent to Colonel Kerney, requesting an escort of dragoons as far as the Platte. This was refused; and as the sequel proved, there was no occasion for it. The St. Joseph emigrants were as good Christians and as zealous Mormon-haters as the rest..." (Chapter 4)
Historically, your Christian faith was often defined by who you hated. Being Catholic meant that you despised Jews, the Christ-killers of Antiquity; being a Protestant meant that you hated the Catholic church and the same would go for the subdivisions of these groups. That seems to have been the big difference between Jesus and Christendom: he was defined by who he loved, not by who he hated.
I don't know if Jesus himself would have been able to foster a sense of brotherhood between Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda. I don't know that any religion has ever managed to restrain human tribal passions. What happened there--and in the death camps of the 3rd Reich--is primarily an indictment of humanity. To blame Christianity you would first have to prove that it was within the power of Christianity to overcome hatred that's been festering for centuries.
Aage
Kieth's misdiagnoses of Rwanda tragedy is surprising since Paul Rusesabagina was the subject of his piece. He calls it a failure of Christanity when Paul Rusesabagina succinctly proves it wasn't.
When Israel was doing everything wrong was it a failure of God? Of course not. It is a simplistic and flawed reasoning from cause to effect. Its akin to saying a group of people who were bad at math was the fault of mathematics.
Michael
That sentiment is just below the surface in some Adventists. I remember sitting next to a church pastor in a board meeting which was a "witch hunt" trying to determine which of its members had attended an "off-shoot" meeting one Sabbath. The pastor, sitting next to me, mumbled "get rid of the apostates" and several members stood up to demand that those who attended this meeting were "apostates" and should be disfellowshipped then and there. Names were requested of those who attended so action could be taken immediately.
Shortly thereafter, the new pastor of the church gave a blistering sermon labeling those who had begun this new church planting as "Korah, Dathan, and Abiram" and summarily called for their disfellowship at the worship hour! Chilling to hear the audio tape.
Elaine
If it's OK to quote from D**dw**d, the grudging admiration for the character who is Fluent in both languages and don't mind standing in filth has some bearing on how Christians go about their business.
Chris Hedges' This Time We’re Taking the Whole Planet With Us chills to the bone.
Jesus was able to foster a sense of brotherhood between estranged ethnic groups who had a history of killing each other, an example is the Jews and Samaritans (See John 4). The genocide described in this article is what you would expect from a non-Christian world. Christianity did fail in that the majority of Christian people acted out of selfish, racist hatred instead of Christian love.
I heard a lot about the time of trouble growing up. It occurs to me that in the case of Rwanda, and many other places, much of humanity has already experienced the time of trouble. For Christians, and Adventists in particular, however, oppression and violence only seem to attract attention when the Christian's right to worship is infringed or their right not to be offended is challenged.
How do prevent genocide from occuring in the United States?
Anon: "How to prevent genocide from occuring in the United States?" We can start by refusing to participate in the self-righteous and mean-spirited slap downs ("spiritual genocide") of those whose interpretations of Bible verses, prophecy and E.G.W. differ from our own cherished sacred cows.
Patti Cottrell Grant
Add your comment